Economics is the study of the allocation of scarce resources with alternative uses. It sounds like esoteric mumbo jumbo. But all it means is that the world has stuff we want and that we can’t all have that stuff and the market decides how it all gets divvied out.
It’s one of the more important ideas in human society because it affects everything in life, from the time we’re born to the day we die—even in societies where money doesn’t exist—like hunter-gatherer ones. People in all societies have to decide who gets what and at what cost, whether it’s in gold, seashells, land or blood.
Prices reflect the value of things. A price doesn’t have to be monetary. A price is simply a psychological agreement point on an economic exchange. The dating world is one area where colorful economic calculations go on all the time, but most people just don’t realize it.
Every man wants a beautiful girl. But every guy eventually realizes that you can’t be a loser and get a beautiful girl. You have to invest in yourself. You need to keep yourself in good physical condition and have a good occupation, or at least seem ambitious enough that you’ll be somebody some day. And if you’re ugly, but you’re rich, you could still get the beautiful girl. A beautiful woman knows she can trade her beauty for the best of these things. Beautiful women are expensive because there are more men who want beautiful women than there are beautiful women. Of course, there are other factors that come into play in the mating game, but that’s the fundamental calculation.
The concept of price even exists in other species. Female chimpanzees, for example, are known to trade sex for food. Apparently male chimps think a quick casual sexual encounter is worth giving up a hard-won piece of meat for. It’s no different than some guy in a seedy motel negotiating a price with a hooker.
The price of anything depends on its absolute supply and the demand there is for it. Take a look at the graphs below.
The top one represents how prices functioned in 20th century economies. Where the supply and demand lines meet on each of those graphs is where you have a price. The bottom one reflects 21st century digitally-based economies. 20th century economies were based largely around the production of scarce resources. Demand for those resources was therefore relatively high. People are willing to pay for most things in that type of economy precisely because they’re scarce. But look at where the supply and demand lines meet on the 21st century graph. It’s at a much lower point on the graph. That’s because abundance is the norm in digital economies.
In many industries affected by digital economics, the price of things, especially software, trend to zero. The music industry is one area that’s been rocked by this phenomenon. Although not every aspect of it. Mostly the music itself.
FREE is sometimes a controversial word . But it depends on what side of the economic exchange you’re on. If you’re a creator of music or a record label, it’s probably not a word you want to hear too often. But free is just a symptom of technology. The owners of bit torrent sites that provide free media to the public aren’t necessarily out to kill the music industry. Some may be bent on world domination, but I’m sure the vast majority of them are just taking advantage of rapid advances in technology that allow them to create these portals to make money indirectly. The music industry is never going to disappear.
It’s still very healthy, but what’s happening is that the scarcity points where prices are possible are shifting to different parts of the industry or outside the industry altogether.
Beach front property is expensive because there are far more people who want a house on the beach than there are houses on the beach. But imagine if somebody invented a virtual reality machine that could neurologically reproduce the exact same experience as spending a week or two at the beach house. Demand for real beach front property would plummet and so would beach front property prices. But the inventor of the virtual reality machine would be raking in cash as people started buying up his gadget. So people would still pay for the experience, but to manufacturers of beach front virtual reality machines instead of beach front property owners.
The bit torrent sites and all the new technologies that surround the easy production, duplication and distribution of music in the digital age are the equivalent of the virtual reality machine in that they’ve shifted the value points of the industry from the music itself to other areas like iPods and concerts.
Apple raked in billions through its iPod and iTunes at the expense of the labels. But you can’t call Apple unfair for doing that. They were just smart. They saw the economic trends and figured out what the future was going to look like.
The secret to making money in any industry is to figure out where the scarcity is. And for something to be scarce, it has to be hard to do. So that means that the people who make money are going to be the savviest, most persistent and hardest workers.


April 20th, 2010 at 11:19 am
If you have the biggest and the best names of the music available 24/7/365 for free on the web and if you can carry this music anywhere through a wireless device to watch videos or listen to the mp3 I ask why you would pay for this songs ? And why you would pay for a song from a band or artist unknown ?
You may not have all the songs in the world stored somewhere in your house but you have all the songs in the world available to enjoy on the web . Thousands and thousands ! And for free . Then why pay for it ? And why have all the songs in the world ( in your preferred style ) downloaded on your mobile device or HD ? You really have time to listen to all this ?
As an indie musician , I am distressed to learn that ( on the moment ) a versatile environment like the web does not provide the opportunity for a good monthly income for my livelihood . I am sad to see that really is true that the word ‘free’ applies to the created work because we all want compensation for the money that was invested and for our daily struggle to survive . I am even more concerned about those people who have no other choice but to give up a dream in the name of money on this time of decanting . These people need to keep the own dream alive .
I still see the web as an excellent means of distribution and exposure . This is undeniable . The web is a multifaceted business card and therein lies the good side . People worldwide have access to what you created . Not so good ? So , let’s keep uploading …
Everything has a price in this life ( for free , offline , only air and ground ) : if you can host your videos and mp3 for free through the web as you might think about making money with them ? The web is free , so what you have created and published also will be . It is an environment , a liquid , and the rule at the moment is this and we must accept and go ahead .
Now is the moment of truth , where the musicians who work with real love of art will continue insisting on creating sounds each time better by sheer passion and dedication , for the future . It is time to see and feel who are the musicians that are artists and musicians that are capitalists . This difficulty is a huge filter.
I think that ( today ) money is made through shows , merch after that , dripping sweat on stage and in the face to face …
April 21st, 2010 at 10:44 am
Totally agree: music that is almost effortless to make with software will generally not make you any money.
Your sound should be something that is not easy to do, and something you can reproduce live in concert.
April 23rd, 2010 at 10:48 am
I agree with what you said but the reality about making money with touring is less than before too. I know many bands that went on tour in the last 2 years and came back, not with money but, with a debt of 10,000 and more. The cost of traveling, tour bus, …went up.
For local bands in Quebec, now the bar are charging money to play in their place. I used to be paid to play in bars but now their is so many bands out there…it makes it easy to book their place and charge for it, quality is not required anymore as long as the band pay, their expenses are cover. Pay to play started in Toronto, expended to all the big city in Canada but now it has expended to the regions too, so you have to pay the bar before you see any money for the bands.
Merch seems the new way to make money but it means that the bands have to invest first (again) hoping people will buy their stuff. And some venues charge a percentage on what you’ve sold… Everybody makes money on the back of musicians these days. Not only apple and company.
Why I still have a band? Cause I love to play music…that”s about it.
April 23rd, 2010 at 11:43 am
Thanx for the economics lesson Mika!
Very very interesting stuff as usual. This article is great because it’s showing us how the music industry is made up of just more that rhythms and melodies. Most people striving to be professionals realize this on some basic level. For me, articles like this really get my brain going about the fundementals of our industry and it helps re-establish the importance of understanding more than the music itself.
Thank you again Mika. Looking forward to the next post.
Take care – j0hn